Value
light or dark
True Summer has medium contrast: hair is usually ash brown or ash blonde, never blue-black. Black is the darkest value there is, so it sits darker than anything in your coloring and becomes the strongest thing in the picture.
True Summer is also called Cool Summer.
Right temperature, too much contrast. Wear it low, and soft navy up top.
The short answer
True Summer, also called Cool Summer, should keep black away from the face. Black matches the cool undertone but is far too dark and stark for medium-contrast True Summer coloring, so it overpowers the features and can look severe. Wear black below the waist, and use soft navy, cool charcoal or slate grey as the dark neutral near the face.
Black is not a temperature problem for True Summer, it is a strength problem. These four darks are just as cool and a few steps gentler.
Soft navy
#2A4C7D
your best dark neutral
Cool charcoal
#48464C
the softest way to say black
Slate grey
#627178
for knits and trousers
Denim navy
#32527C
a touch lighter and more casual
Jet black
#000001
right temperature, too much contrast
Ink purple
#270068
dark and intense like black
Optic white
#F5F5F6
black and white, too stark together
light or dark
True Summer has medium contrast: hair is usually ash brown or ash blonde, never blue-black. Black is the darkest value there is, so it sits darker than anything in your coloring and becomes the strongest thing in the picture.
clear or muted
True Summer colors are soft rather than clear. Black is absolute, with no softness in it, which is why it reads severe on you even though it is cool. Navy and charcoal carry the same coolness with a little softness.
The shift that fixes it
Jet black
Soft navy
Black works below the shoulders: trousers, skirts, shoes, bags. At the neckline, put a palette color between black and your face, like a raspberry top, a powder blue shirt collar or a dove grey scarf.
If black is in the outfit, these True Summer shades soften it:
Dove grey
a soft layer at the neckline
Raspberry
brings life back to the face
Powder blue
fresh and cool against black
Soft white
the light neutral, instead of optic
Black leaves True Summer looking pale, so add soft cool color: a raspberry or rose lip, a cool pink blush and grey or soft plum eyeshadow. Silver or white gold jewelry, never brassy gold.
The common mistake is thinking black is fine because it is cool. Temperature is only half of it. The other half is depth and softness, and that is where soft navy beats black every time on True Summer.
Match the job black usually does to the shade that does it better on you:
Soft navy
for suits, coats and the office
#2a4c7d
Cool charcoal
for trousers and evening
#48464c
Slate grey
for everyday knitwear
#627178
Berry
for the dress that would have been black
#b33f75
The answer on this page only holds if the season is right. For these neighbouring types, the verdict on black changes.
True Winter is the cool season that wears black brilliantly. If soft navy looks weak on you and black looks sharp, compare True Summer with True Winter.
Soft Summer avoids black even more firmly and goes softer still, toward slate and plum grey. If navy looks a little too crisp on you, compare the two.
Your exact season, your full palette, the neutrals that work for you and the makeup shades that match, all from one photo.
Get my color analysis